The Appropriate Environment
This is the post I have put off over and over because I was unsure of what, exactly, to write.
Then a few people caught my passing reference on Twitter to homeschooling the T-Bot and I received requests for information.
So, yes. I am now homeschooling the T-Bot. The problem with writing about it is, I am still not quite sure why. I mean, obviously I am aware of the events which eventually led us to pull him out of school overnight. But that was just the climax of a very stressful school year-plus-six-weeks, where everything and anything seemed to go horribly wrong for him.
I have gone around and around and around thinking about this. Just over a year ago I sent the school a happy, outgoing, confident little boy who was very excited about starting kindergarten. A little socially immature and not quite there with language, a little excitable, but generally well behaved in both home and social environments. To cut a long story short, that is not the child they handed back to my care at the end of every school day.
I hoped things would go well this year. The T-Bot was back to his normal self over the long summer vacation and was excited at the prospect of making new friends. Instead, he became doubly anxious, at home as at school, and everything just, for want of a better phrase, blew up.
I can’t assign blame. There are too many factors to consider. Consider a child already prone to anxiety, a large, impersonal school environment with an extreme emphasis on independence from a young age, a strict “zero-tolerance” policy, daily teasing and minor bullying, subtle lingering problems with language, cultural differences, immaturity, boredom with those interminable worksheets, a fear of tests and failure, an intense longing to fit in combined with an almost total lack of guile (he tripped me so it must be cool to trip him…. oh, I got caught), being a six year old, being a boy.
One thing I do know. These problems are mostly environmental. And that calls for a change of environment.
I am just sorry I didn’t do it earlier. Why didn’t I? Because truly, I didn’t want to homeschool. With my last child just starting in the preschool system, I was *this* far away from getting my independence. From next year I would have been able to work, uninterrupted, all day, every weekday, rather than carving out time here and there and mostly after 9pm.
I have been having brief pity parties. My life expectations changed overnight so I think I am entitled. But then I have also been in awe of the T-Bot and how, in a fun and relaxed learning environment, he is so motivated to learn. That’s all I am asking him to do, is learn, the best way he knows how. I am not ordering him to memorize 20 meaningless phonograms, complete two graded tests a week, fill in worksheet after worksheet with drawings of eight things next to the number eight or three things next to the number three, walk around our house two steps behind me with his hands behind his back. Jump through any No Child Left Behind style hoops at all. I do ask him to sit still, concentrate on what we are doing, listen to and follow the instructions. I do ask him to read and write about things that interest him. I do ask him to look at math patterns and how numbers are interrelated until it clicks and he has one of those “wow” moments. I ask him to look at word patterns the same way (did any of us truly learn to spell “work” by memorizing that when -or is preceded by w it can sound like -er ??) . I do ask him to do worksheets, in 5 minute bursts, emphasizing all the way that it will not take long. And when we have finished all this, as a treat, I let him do science experiments.
In the end, I guess, the reason for homeschooling the T-Bot turns out to be very simple. The local public school was unable to teach him in an appropriately stress-free environment.
At the time we removed him from school I was halfway through reading Richard Lavoie’s The Motivation Breakthrough. It was the book which gave me the courage to finally make the break with the public school system. Not because the book advocates that - far from it - but because the solutions in the book require some flexibility and ingenuity from both educators and parents. And how can I ask that of an elementary teacher already feeling the weight of the required standardized testing? How can I ask that of a system which has no provisions for seeing past mediocre test results to my sons real and very apparent abilities, a system with an authoritarian bent which prefers to repeatedly punish minor transgressions rather than take a good hard look at making school fun so that children are interested and engaged?
I have been reading other books too. About boys and why they are failing in ever greater numbers, being given questionable diagnoses in ever greater numbers. Being drugged in ever greater numbers. I think everybody with a boy - no matter what his character - should read at least one of these. The Minds of Boys is a good one but there is plenty of choice
.
I know there are people out there who will read this and think I am an apologist for my child, probably just a lazy boy with disciplinary issues. Obviously these are people who know far more about my child than I do. Let me just say this. There are children that fit in fine in a public school environment. And then there are those who don’t. I just feel fortunate that, like it or not, I have the opportunity to create the appropriate learning environment for my son. I am confident about his future now, because it is in my hands.
And truly, we have all breathed a sigh of relief.

October 19th, 2008 at 1:33 pm
Wow. Good for you for doing what is obviously best for your son. Public school expects kids to fit in a certain way and some kids just don’t. I worry that some kids get labeled at the outset as difficult, smart, unable to focus, quiet or whatever and then it’s hard for them to break out of that. Does that make any sense? I worry all the time that my twins will constantly get compared to each other when they are so different and approach school in such a different way.
I don’t know if I could home school. Although, as a mom you do what you need to do for your kids. I admire you for taking it on.
October 19th, 2008 at 4:01 pm
Wow, Sophie! Kudos to you, for being able to change gears overnight. I know it’s tough, changing your plans and giving up so much of yourself. But look at him go! Wow. And it sounds like you’re an amazing teacher!
My daughter is almost 5 and in Kindergarten. It took me SO long to find the right school environment for her. I seriously started looking when she was two! As she gets through this first trimester of school, I am assured over and over again that by choosing a Charter School, we made the absolute best decision for her. I think, if ever you are considering putting the T-Bot back into mainstream school, that you might look into that option. Not all Charter Schools are created equal, by any means, but some of them far surpass the word “Excellent”.
I don’t want to write you a book, but here are some examples of the way our charter school is different from regular public school:
They use love and logic (www.loveandlogic.com).
They do staggered learning for each subject. For example, if a child in 1st grade needs a litte more help reading, he/she would work with the kindergarten class for reading, and if a KG kid already had a lot of those reading concepts down, they would work with the 1st grade class. There’s no stigma to it, because they mix it up all the time.
In each class, they also mix the kids up so they can learn at their own pace, learn from each other, and have some individual time to work with the teacher.
Parents are expected to do 30 hours of volunteer time each school year. That way, they are more involved and there are parent helpers around ALL the time. More eyes = less harrassment.
Newsletters are sent home EVERY friday.
Progress Reports are sent home EVERY month, and they cover not only the school subjects but also the social aspect, peer acceptance, confidence in learning, etc.
They encourage kids to learn in a myriad of ways: visual, audio, kinesthetic, repetition.
They encourage volunteerism, patriotism, compassion, and empathy.
Also, ours has a uniform policy so there are no worries about being singled out for clothing.
In short, if I could create a school, it would be the exact replica of the Charter School where my daughter goes. I’m sure we’ll run into problems at some point, but based on the feedback I’ve gotten from other parents, it’s just a great environment!
October 24th, 2008 at 3:01 pm
No matter the homeschooler, no matter the child, or situation, or location, it seems like we all have a post like this. Every time I read one of these “We were up against a wall” posts, it breaks my heart, because I was up against that wall too.
We’re in a very small community, and we have 1 public school. I could drive to the next town and put our kids in A-another public school, but these ones are a bit higher-preforming, or a VERY expensive Catholic private school. Oh how I wish we had charter schools like Andrea talks about.
I’m really glad that you were so proactive with your son, that’s what signed it for me. I thought “Can I lay awake til 4am wondering if it’ll ever get better, if my son is being damaged or slighted any longer? How will I feel in a year, 3 years, 10 years, if I just let this happen for lack of action….” It’s really not worth the risk, is it?
Thank you so much for stopping by my blog, I hope you’ll continue to come back! We can help each other out in this crazy new world we find ourselves in